Regarding the constitution that is ideal or “according to prayer,” aristotle criticizes the views of his predecessors in politics and then offers a rather sketchy blueprint of his own in politics vii and viii. Machiavelli vs aristotle: ideal state was more concerned with definitions of past states and criticisms as well as providing explanations that would make it . Aristotle accepted many of the views of plato, particularly plato’s concept of an ideal state but he disagreed with plato’s theory of communism aristotle believed that unity of the state is necessary, but not at the cost of identity of individuals. Aristotle on the ideal constitution a further criticism of aristotle the main problem with which aristotle leaves us is why, if the best of the possible constitutions is one in which anyone may prosper, ie attain happiness and fulfill themselves, why are most people excluded from this possibility. In book two of aristotle’s politics, aristotle defines his ideal state by criticizing the values put forward in plato’s the republic in doing so, aristotle censures plato’s idea of state unification through sharing as much as possible, including wives, children, and property aristotle .
Criticism of aristotle on the ideal state essay question #1 ancient greek philosopher aristotle wrote the nicomachean ethics, portraying the significance of studying the realms of ethics and political science. Aristotle's discussion of plato's ideal republic had the potential to be one of the greatest intellectual encounters of all time but is instead painfully unsatisfying aristotle seems to be misreading plato almost intentionally, and he rarely levels criticism of any value. For aristotle, democracy is not the best form of government as is also true of oligarchy and monarchy, rule in a democracy is for and by the people named in the government type in a democracy, rule is by and for the needy in contrast, rule of law or aristocracy (literally, power [rule] of the .
Aristotle widely regarded as a realist, outlined his ideal state in book ii, iii, viii of his “politics” a comparison between idealism of plato and aristotle is best illustrated by sabine, “what aristotle calls the ideal state is always plato’s second best” while plato hails his ideal . An effective means to the realization of the ideal city-state4 it is my purpose at the present to examine aristotle's criticism of the platonic perfect polity in order to determine. Aristotle did not approve of the three classes of plato’s ideal state, especially the guardians having the political power with them aristotle’s criticism of .
What are some criticisms of plato and his philosophy is highly criticized by aristotle in his book politics his concept of ideal state has been criticized . A comparison of plato's and aristotle's conceptions of state - zach von naumann - essay - philosophy - philosophy of the ancient world - publish your bachelor's or master's thesis, dissertation, term paper or essay. Aristotle's critique of plato's ideal states equally closely underlie his criticism of plato's ideal state in aristotle's ideal state are inimical to plato .
For both, the end of the state is ethical as justice is the basis for the ideal state for plato, the individual and the state are one, as they both have a tripartite nature of which justice is the result of a sound balance of these three parts. Neither plato nor aristotle found it to be necessary to distinguish between the state nor society and therefore it is difficult to define polis (hacker 77) the polis was set up to allow political participation on the part of the average citizen (hacker 80). It is my research work that discusses the theory of forms and aristotle's criticism on this powerful theory search search the ideal state/society of plato and .
The place of the polity in aristotle's theory of the ideal state william t bluhm university of rochester t he tradition of aristotelian scholarship has always distin-. For aristotle, social life in a community is a necessary condition for a man's complete flourishing as a human being aristotle explains that friendship, the mutual admiration between two human beings, is a necessary condition for the attainment of one's eudaimonia . At its heart, aristotle's ideal state, whatever its specific form of government, maintains its legitimacy by serving the good life for the people as a whole. Aristotle's criticism of plato's theoretic proposltlon that itproclaims aristotle'sintention to devise an ideal politieal eonstruet (plato) with a positive .